I find it very interesting when people say they've made certain parenting choices because they're lazy.*
I mostly hear it in reference to co-sleeping, along the lines of "We co-sleep because I'm too lazy to get out of bed at night."
Perhaps there are some instances where this is the case, but I actually kind of doubt it. For example, if you thought co-sleeping was completely unsafe, you wouldn't potentially put your child's life at risk just because you were lazy. (For the record, it can be perfectly safe, but that's not the point here.) If you co-sleep, you've probably decided to do it because that's the best way for everyone in your family to get the most sleep. Yes, much of that decision probably hinges on not having to get up in order to feed the baby, but I would consider that more a matter of making your life easier rather than succumbing to laziness.
The other thing about claiming laziness as motivation is that it can often be used to justify the opposite as well. Take breastfeeding, for example. A mother could make the case that she nurses exclusively because she's too lazy to deal with formula, making and cleaning bottles, etc. But at the same time another mother could make the case that she only uses bottles because she's too lazy to be the one to always feed the baby - this way her husband/mother/babysitter/whoever can do more of the work. The rationale of laziness can be used in multiple ways.
Laziness could be justification of starting solids with your baby as finger foods (no separate meals) or with buying jars (no cleaning up after making homemade purees). Laziness could be claimed in using elimination communication (fewer diaper changes and earlier potty training) or in using diapers past toddlerhood (no diaper wars and no accidents on floors).
The funny thing is, I only hear about laziness in reference to the "crunchier" choices. Perhaps that's because these mothers** know their choices aren't necessarily mainstream and they want to justify it without getting into a debate and sounding like they're looking down on other mother's choices? Perhaps it's because the mothers who are making the choices to do otherwise already have enough people making them feel guilty and they aren't about to denigrate what they're doing?
I don't really know. What I do know is that in most cases, there's a lot more going into these choices than just a mother's sloth. (I don't even really need to list the factors - expenses, father's role, daily care situation, etc.) These choices are made based on what's best for that particular family at that particular time - and I think the family will naturally tend to view them as the easiest solutions.
For the record, I don't think any of these things are being lazy, because so far I've found that laziness is fairly incompatible with parenthood. Even if you wanted to be lazy, you're still doing a heck of a lot of work!
So is it a disservice to label something as the "lazy choice"? Is it even accurate? Would it be better to call it the easier choice for that family, or am I just overanalyzing? Have you joked about making parenting choices based on laziness?
* I'm not meaning this to be a critique, more just an observation - so if you've said this before please don't think I'm criticizing you personally!
** Let's be honest, it's not the dads saying this - heaven help the father who talks about being lazy in reference to caring for his child!
I think you hit the nail on the head with this:
ReplyDelete"Have you joked about making parenting choices based on laziness?"
And this:
"they want to justify it without getting into a debate"
This from a mom of four who has done some things very crunchy (breastfeeding, cosleeping, home birth) and has spent lots of time around similarly-minded women and heard lots of these conversations.
I'm also a mom that sleep trains and uses spanking, so I've got one foot in both 'camps', so to speak.
As a side note, as I've become an older person and parent (my oldest is nine), these topics become less polarizing and more along the lines of what you said here:
"These choices are made based on what's best for that particular family at that particular time"
So, yes, you are over analyzing but I have no advice for that because I did the exact.same.thing.
Congratulations on motherhood!!
I have NEVER said that I've made any parenting choice out of laziness, especially in regards to us using formula. Mostly because I am afraid that most breastfeeding moms already think I'm lazy for using formula (which maybe they don't and I'm just paranoid?). In fact, I think it *is* a lot of work to use formula, as I am learning now that we're planning for a trip. We have to take along all the bottles, plus cans of formula. Washing bottles every day and making them takes about 40 minutes. So I don't really know how any formula using mom can really claim that it's "laziness" motivating their choice. On the other hand, I rarely get up in the night for feedings, and that my friend, is sheer laziness. :)
ReplyDeleteI definitely use the laziness card when explaining my parenting choices. I think, for me, because a lot of our choices are outside the mainstream way of doing things, I am afraid that other mothers will think that I think I am somehow better than them. So I kind of use "laziness" as a way of telling them that I don't think that.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I think a lot of people can think some of these parenting choices can be really difficult (e.g. breastfeeding on demand, baby-led solids), and this is my way of communicating that I think it is not so hard as some might make out.
I think it would be better to say "this is what fits my family, our individual personalities, within this specific time and place in our lives", but I guess that takes more time to express. And hey, I'm lazy ;)
I guess I've stopped justifying anything I do to anyone, LOL. And I usually tell people they don't have to justify what they do to anyone. You do what ya gotta do...and whatever works for your family at any particular time.
ReplyDeletemy MIL and my Sister have both claimed "laziness" for why they breastfed their babies...but I breastfed one of mine and I'm here to tell ya, that is NOT a lazy choice, in my opinion!
I'm not exactly sure what you're referring to in this post, but since you pointed out that any parenting choice can be deemed 'lazy' by someone, it seems that its just an easy way to discuss something without really discussing it. A 'lazy' attempt at comedy to avoid the mommy wars, if you will ;)
ReplyDeletelol, well.... i am lazy :-p
ReplyDeletehttp://stsebastianprayforus.blogspot.com/2011/02/dont-judge-me.html
i wrote a post that touched on this. honestly, my choices - cloth, BFing, cosleeping, etc. - are definitely what works for our family because they require minimum effort for maximum output - they result in healthy, happy babies, and they "feel" like the best choice. ie. mama instinct.
i use the lazy parenting as a joke, to be sure, but i think part of the glory of some of the "crunchier" choices is that they don't overcomplicate things. sometimes the best choice doesn't have to be the hardest choice!
(also, we spank as well, OP, and man does that get looks in some crunchy/AP circles!)
Guilty, guilty, and guilty! I've actually seen this recommended as a way to deflect criticism for choosing to stay at home ("I'm selfish; I want to be with my kid."). I have a lot of friends who don't get this attachment parenting stuff, so it's an easy out-- it's harder to argue about personality traits than childrearing ideology. Perhaps I'm a chicken, but I really don't want those friends to think that I'm judging them for their parenting choices. It's such a fine line to walk between discussing your viewpoints and being militant!
ReplyDeleteI hope that they are just using it as an excuse to defer the mommy wars and not as an actually reason. I say this because true laziness in parenting can cause all sorts of problems later on if a parent is truly "checking out" of being a parent - i.e. making prepackaged meals so the parent can go watch tv and ignore their children vs. making prepackaged meals because it's the best way of avoid the fast food restaurant after a day of work, school, afterschool activities in order to give parents and kids a little more time to talk around the dinner table, play a game or watch a movie together.
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with the folks above...using the term lazy is probably just a way to avoid an argument.
ReplyDeleteIt may not even be accurate to say it is the "easier" choice for the family. It's probably more the "right choice for us."
None of our choices as mothers and wives are easy, are they? I agonize over many of them. Breast or formula, cloth-disposable-EC, organic or non-organic, swaddle or non-swaddling, homeschool-public school-private school-unschooling, daycare or leaving the little one home to fend for themselves for the day (just kidding ;)), work outside the home or work inside my home exclusively.
Ahhhh!!!! The choices! You're right though, there are positives and negatives for each choice we make...and they all balance out differently on each of our scales.
Yes, I have used the "because I'm lazy" line as a joke, like when writing a blog post on "Why do I co-sleep?" I might have begin with: "Short answer: because I'm lazy," and then gone into all the actual reasons for why I really do what I do.
ReplyDeleteI have heard people say to mothers who co-sleep, "You know, you chose to be a parent, and parents are just supposed to be sleep-deprived! parents are supposed to do the work of sleep-training their babies," and otherwise implied that co-sleeping is done out of a laziness for not wanting to deal with sleep-training. I always say that no, parents are not supposed to be sleep-deprived, and parents are not supposed to be wrestling with "sleep-training" difficulties, and perhaps there is a real biological reason why our babies tend to sleep better with us: because mothers need sleep, too, and we can do what is natural and get that biological need of sleep met for both ourselves and our babies. If God built it into our human nature, into our biology, then it should not be classified as "lazy." In fact, it can get to the point of being very child-centric when a mother obsesses over her young baby's nap being at the exact same time and always in his crib to the point that she feels trapped in her home... isn't it much less child-centric to have the baby napping on the mother in a sling while she's out? And I realize that doesn't work forever... many toddlers won't sleep like this because they want to be involved in what's going on around them! I often hear people saying that attachment parenting is so child0-centric, but I can see it the other way, too, when the baby has to have his own room and own bed from the first days of his life...
And you are right - no matter what parenting decisions are made, it is still hard work regardless! By going with my babies' biology and embracing and accepting the way they are, it has been more enjoyable for me, though!